October 23, 2017
Archives  News  IMG Reviews SimCity 4  Comments  


IMG Reviews SimCity 4
Tuesday, July 29, 2003 1:00 PM | Tuncer Deniz
Back   Return to article


Performance is in the toilet
Brian Arnold December 09 - 9:15 PM

I am sorry, performance is a relative thing, and it's in the pooper for SimCity.

I do not accept "souped up" or "need the top of the line" or "upgrade your graphics card".

That's a lot of B.S. to avoid the fact that this game was not designed to scale well, performance-wise. SimCity 4 was designed to play great on the fastest most amazing computers available, which very, very few of us have, and it does not play well on those computers the rest of us have.

One should not need to soup up a currently-shipping Apple computer, or soup up what was a year ago a top-of-the-line computer, or what has been updated as best it can for a four year old computer....whew...to play a game. In a way that doesn't horribly suck, performance-wise.

I have tried SimCity 4 on a PowerBook G4, a brand new iBook G4, and an old crufty Blue & White upgraded with a G4 500MHz and ATI Radeon 7000 32MB, and...there is not a one of them that plays this game well, in terms of performance. Q.E.D.


Review
Tuncer (IMG) July 30 - 9:51 AM

I'm sure if the reviewer had issues with the performance, she would have said something. Performance is such a relative thing. For some, 30 FPS is not enough. For others, it's fine. SimCity 4 runs on my machine just fine, but maybe it's because I have a supped up machine, a great video card, etc.

In the future, please write user reviews in the review itself. Posting comments here is, well, kinda useless.


Hmmm...
Lance Moody July 30 - 7:59 AM

I commented earlier and it disappeared.

I said that it was hard to believe that a review would overlook the poor performance of this game even on high-end systems (as documented in your own forums).

Also it would be a nice feature for reviews to mention the porting company since many now have bad track records and this game makes no mention of who ported it.

Please e-mail me if the only comments you are requesting are along the lines of:

"Awesome review, dude!"

instead of anthing critical,

Lance

lancemoody@mac.com


Daedel July 30 - 12:53 AM

Thank you for finally reviewing this thing!



Article Comments Closed

This article is too old to post any new comments too. If you would like to discuss the issues relating to this article, you may do so freely in the Inside Mac Games Forums. Thank You.


News Headlines for Tuesday, July 29, 2003

IMG Reviews SimCity 4 1:00 PM
Descent: FreeSpace, FreeSpace 2 for OS X Update 12:30 PM
Tomb Raider Game Blamed for Weak Movie Opener 10:55 AM
Aspyr Posts Indiana Jones Trailer 10:23 AM
IMG Store: Dungeon Siege for $39.95 8:47 AM
Neverwinter Nights Gold on July 25th 8:35 AM
GarageGames Interview at DailyGame 8:35 AM
Wrestler Maxx Payne Sues Max Payne 8:35 AM
 
View all of the news for Tuesday, July 29, 2003 on one page


Recent News

Monday, July 28, 2003
Friday, July 25, 2003
Thursday, July 24, 2003
Wednesday, July 23, 2003
Tuesday, July 22, 2003


Search for other news stories or browse our News Archive.



Archives  News  IMG Reviews SimCity 4  Comments